Support and Against Historical Cost Accounting: Is it Value Relevance for Decision Making?

Evi Rahmawati

Abstract


This paper reviews the issues on the support and criticism of historical cost accounting (HCA) and the incremental information content on current cost disclosures. Based on literature review this study find that historical cost is still relevant to use in decision making. Empirical studies show evidence both; supporting historical cost accounting and criticisms against the conventional historical cost based financial statements. Issues on historical cost are raised because of  economic condition, inflation, the change in high tech environment, price movements, and regulators statements. Studies shows that historical cost accounting. over the decade: still have power explanatory for investors, which indicates that its benefits outweigh its cost. However, Barth et al. (1996) provide strong evidence on incremental information of current cost disclosures for certain assets and liabilities. This paper concludes that even there are weaknesses (against) HCA, still there are more benefits that we can gain through HCA.


Keywords


Historical Cost Accounting; Current Cost; Value Relevance

Full Text:

Download Article

References


Aldrige, C.R and Colbert, J.L. (1997). "We Need Better Financial Reporting". Strategic Finance. pp 32-36.

Australian Bureau of Statistics."National Customer Price Index" as retrieved from www.abs.gov.au available on May 15 2004.

Australian Accounting Research Foundation (1998)."Measurement in Financial Acounting-Acconting theory Monograph 10"

Ball, R & Brown, P (1968). "An Empirical Examination of Accounting Income Numbers". Journal of Accounting Research, Vol.6 No 2, pp. 159-178.

Barth, M.. Beaver. W. H. and Landsman, W. R. (1996). "Value-Relevance of Banks Fair Value Disclosures Under SFAS No. 107". The Accounting Revielv.71, 4, pp 513-537.

Beaver, W.H, and Landsman, W.R.L.(1983)."Incremental Information Content of Statement 33 Disclosure. Stamford.

Beaver, W.H et al. (1980)."The information Content of SEC Accounting Sries Release no 190*".Journal ofAccounting and Economics. 2.pp 127-157.

Collins D.W et al. (1997)."Changes in the Value-relevance of Earnings and Book values over the past forty years." Journal of Accounting and Economics.24.pp 39-67.

Edward, E and Bell, P.(1961)."The Theory and Measurements of Business Income". Berkeley.

Elliott, B and E11iott.2002. "Financial Accounting Reporting and Analysis". Prentice Hall.England.

Duncan, K and Moores, K.(1988)."Usefulness of CCA Information for Investor Decision Making:A Laboratpty Experiment" Accounting and Business Reseurch.Vol 18; 70.pp.121-132.

Ford Motor Quarterly Financial Result. (2004). as cited from http://www.ford.con,ien/ com am inuestorlnformation/companyReportsifinancialResults;default.hhn on May IS 2004.

Gheyara, K and Boatsman. J. (1980). "Market Reaction to the 1976 Replacement Cost Disclosures"'. Journal of Accounting and Economics. 2 pp 107-125.

Godfrey. J.. et a1.(2000)."Accounting Theory''.4`" ed.John Wiley & Sons Ltd.Australia.

Hand, J.R.M.(2000)."The Role of Economic Fundamentals, web traffic, and supply and demand in the pricing of U.S. Internet stock''. Working Paper, University of North Carolina.

Ijiri. Y.,(1975).''Theory of Accounting Measurement" Chapter 6.Florida

Mautz, R.K. (1973).''A few Words for Historical Cost". Financial Executive. pp23,

Ragland et al. (l993)."How might market-value statement preserve historical¬cost information? ". Bank Accounting and Finance. Boston.Vol 6,4:pp.24.

Ro, B.T.(1980)."The Adjustment of Security Return to the Disclosure of Replacement Cost Accounting Information". Journal of Accounting and Economics.2.pp 159-189.

SFAS 33 as cited from wvw.fasb.org/st/#fas150 on March 1 2004

SFAS 107 as cited from www.fasb.org,/st/#fas150 on March 1 2004

Shim, E and Larkin, J.M. (1998). "Towards Relevancy in Financial Reporting: Mark-to-Market Accounting".Journal of Applied Business Research, 14; 2; p.33

Sterling. R.R.(1967)."Conservatism: The Fundamental Principle of Valuation in Traditional Accounting". Abacus. pp. 109-132.

Watts, R.L and Zimmerman J.L.(1980)."On the Irrelevance of Replacement Cost Disclosure for Security Prices". Journal of Accounting and Economics.2.pp 9_5¬106.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Bookmark and Share


Office:
Ruang Jurnal Fakultas Ekonomi dan Bisnis UMY
Gedung Ki Bagus Hadikusuma (E4) Lantai 2, Kampus Terpadu Universitas Muhammadiyah Yogyakarta,
Jalan Brawijaya (Lingkar Selatan), Tamantirto, Kasihan, Bantul, Daerah Istimewa Yogyakarta, Indonesia, 55183
Website: journal.umy.ac.id/index.php/ai - E-mail: jai@umy.ac.id

Journal of Accounting and Investment is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License

View My Stats