Punitive Damages in Unfair Dismissal Cases: Lessons from Malaysia and New Zealand

Siti Fazilah Abdul Shukor, Siti Suraya Abd Razak

Abstract


Employers tend to dismiss employees without proper grounds, in bad faith or fail to follow procedure prescribed under law. An employee that has been dismissed unfairly can bring an action against the employer for unfair dismissal. Damage is the most sought remedy of the employee for unfair dismissal claims. Punitive damage is a form of monetary remedy awarded by the court in addition to the actual damage to the aggrieved party. Punitive damage is awarded as a punishment to the wrongdoer. Punitive damage has become the remedy in both Malaysia and New Zealand. The objective of this study is to analyse the punitive damage awarded by the Malaysian Industrial Court and New Zealand Court in unfair dismissal cases. This study employed a qualitative method with reference to journal articles, relevant statutory laws and case laws on unfair dismissal cases with punitive damage as an award. The findings show that punitive damages in unfair dismissal cases have been awarded by the Malaysian industrial court and New Zealand court against employers on the grounds that the dismissals were made under bad faith. This study is significant as it expands the application of punitive damage in unfair dismissal cases and improve the system’s legal certainty.

Keywords


Employment Law; Industrial Relations ;Punitive Damage; Remedy; Unfair Dismissal.

Full Text:

PDF

References


Adar, Yehuda, ‘Whiten v. Pilot Insurance Co.: The Unofficial Death of the Independent Wrong Requirement and Official Birth of Punitive Damages in Contract’, Can. Bus. LJ, 41 (2004), 247.

Adejugbe, Adeyinka A, ‘From Contract to Status: Unfair Dismissal Law’, Journal of Commercial and Property Law, 8.1 (2021).

Alharbi, Meshal Nayef, ‘Assessment of Changes to Saudi Labour Law Regarding Unfair Dismissal of Employees’, International Journal of Law and Management, 63.4 (2021), 369–86.

Anantaraman, V, ‘Retrenchment: Worker Rights and Court Awards in Malaysia’, Indian Journal of Industrial Relations, 39.4 (2004), 533–63.

Anantaraman, Venkatraman, Malaysian Industrial Relations: Law & Practice (Universiti Putra Malaysia Press, 1997).

Ayadurai, Dunston, ‘Industrial Relations in Malaysia: Law and Practice’, Malayan Law Journal, 1996.

Cheong, May, Remedi-Remedi Bagi Kemungkiran Kontrak Di Malaysia (Sweet & Maxwell, 2004).

Corby, Susan, ‘Unfair Dismissal Disputes: A Comparative Study of Great Britain and New Zealand’, Human Resource Management Journal, 10.1 (2000), 79–92.

Covell, Wayne, Keith Lupton, and Jay Forder, Principles of Remedies (LexisNexis Butterworths, 2012).

Doorey, David J, and Andrew Hills, ‘Statutory Unjust Dismissal in Canada: What Is the Value of a Lost Job?’, King’s Law Journal, 33.2 (2022), 318–44.

Employment Court of New Zealand, ‘Annual Statistics’, Employment Court of New Zealand, 2023 https://www.employmentcourt.govt.nz/annual-statistics/.

Fazilah, Siti, Ashgar Ali Ali Mohamad, and Zuraini Abdul Hamid, ‘Monetary Compensation As a Remedy for Unfair Dismissal: A Study in United Kingdom and Malaysia’, IIUM Law Journal, 27.2 (2019), 447–68.

Flaczyk, Conrad, and Nicolas Glaudemans, ‘Moving beyond Uberrima Fides-The General Duty of Honesty in Contractual Performance and Punitive Damage Awards in Anglo-Canadian Contract Law’, Def. Counsel J., 85 (2018), 1.

Gotanda, John Y, ‘Punitive Damages: A Comparative Analysis’, Colum. J. Transnat’l L., 42 (2003), 391.

Hamsin, Muhammad Khaeruddin, Abdul Halim, and Rizaldy Anggriawan, ‘The Consistency of Sharia Principles Application in Murabaha Contracts During the Covid-19 Pandemic’, in Proceedings of the International Conference on Sustainable Innovation on Humanities, Education, and Social Sciences (ICOSI-HESS 2022) (Paris: Atlantis Press SARL, 2022), pp. 104–19 https://doi.org/10.2991/978-2-494069-65-7_11.

Harcourt, Mark, Maureen Hannay, and Helen Lam, ‘Distributive Justice, Employment-at-Will and Just-Cause Dismissal’, Journal of Business Ethics, 115 (2013), 311–25.

Harvey, McGregor, Mcgregor on Damages, 17th edn (London: Sweet & Maxwell, 2003).

Hodgin, R W, and E Veitch, ‘Punitive Damages—Reassessed1’, International & Comparative Law Quarterly, 21.1 (1972), 119–32.

Hussin, Nasimah, ‘Punitive Justice in the Malaysian Criminal Law: Balancing the Rights of Offenders with Those of the Victims’, Journal of Applied Sciences Research, 7.13 (2011), 2399–2404.

Ismail, Suharne, ‘Unfair Dismissal or Unlawful Termination: A Review of Section 20, Industrial Relation Act 1967’, Journal of Law and Governance, 1.1 (2018), 15–24.

Johan, Suwinto, and Luo Yuan Yuan, ‘What Does Financial Institution Termination of Employment Mean in Terms of Labor Law?’, Volksgeist: Jurnal Ilmu Hukum Dan Konstitusi, 2023, 49–59.

Kuklin, Bailey, ‘Punishment: The Civil Perspective of Punitive Damages’, Clev. St. L. Rev., 37 (1989), 1.

Mahomed, A A A, ‘Harsh Manner of Dismissal: A Workers’ Remedy at Common Law and Statute in Selected Countries’, XXXI Journal of Malaysian Bar, 3 (2002).

Mahoney, Richard, ‘New Zealand’s Accident Compensation Scheme: A Reassessment’, The American Journal of Comparative Law, 40.1 (1992), 159–211.

Mészáros, Marián, and Karina Divékyová, ‘Immediate Termination of Employment Relationship by the Employer’, Central European Journal of Labour Law and Personnel Management, 2.2 (2019), 33–43.

Mohamed, Ashgar Ali Ali, Dismissal from Employment and the Remedies (LexisNexis, 2014).

Mohamed, Ashgar Ali Ali, Mohd Akram Shair Mohamed, and Farheen Baig Sardar Baig, ‘Compensatory Award for Unfair Dismissal in Malaysia: Criterions in Assessment of Award’, IJASOS-International E-Journal of Advances in Social Sciences, 2.6 (2016), 668–74.

Nosková, Milena, and Tomáš Peráček, ‘Termination of Employment in the Slovak Republic as a Key Issue of HR Management’, Central European Journal of Labour Law and Personnel Management, 2.2 (2019), 44–59.

Reilly, Amanda, ‘Maori Women, Discrimination and Paid Work: The Need for an Intersectional Approach’, Victoria University of Wellington Law Review, 50.2 (2019), 321–39.

Sales, James B, and Kenneth B Cole Jr, ‘Punitive Damages: A Relic That Has Outlived Its Origins’, Vand. L. Rev., 37 (1984), 1117.

Soh, Kee Bun, ‘Exemplary or Punitive Damages’, Singapore Journal of Legal Studies, July 1998, 1998, 63–97.

Teng, Joshua, and Kailash Kalaiarasu, ‘Divergence and Convergence in the Law of Contractual Penalties and Liquidated Damages Clauses in England, Singapore, and Malaysia’, Liverpool Law Review, 43.2 (2022), 451–75.

ZA, Istianah, M. Khaeruddin Hamsin, Rizaldy Anggriawan, and Andi Agus Salim, ‘Freedom of Contract and Judicial Intervention: Does the Court Have the Right?’, Revista Opinião Jurídica (Fortaleza), 21.36 (2023), 205 https://doi.org/10.12662/2447-6641oj.v21i36.p205-221.2023.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.18196/iclr.v6i1.19623

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright (c) 2023 Siti Fazilah Abdul Shukor, Siti Suraya Abd Razak

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.