A New Industry and Tax Base on Taxing Esports in Indonesia

Ming-Hsi Sung; Wahyudi Umar

doi:10.18196/jmh.20200148

A New Industry and Tax Base on Taxing Esports in Indonesia

Ming-Hsi Sung, Wahyudi Umar

Abstract

Unlike traditional sports that relies on traditional television broadcasting, esports usually adopts live streaming on internet platforms, such as YouTube, as its medium. Through a delicate design of profit sharing, live esports streaming and media have greatly changed the video game industry from sheer family entertainment machine makers into a new frontier of money making sport, and therefore the game players into a profession that may make billion dollars annually. This paper intends to introduce the current situation of esports in Indonesia, asserting the potential to collect tax from live game streamers (Content Creators) and YouTube (Platform), and players from this newly developed sports industry to broaden the tax base in Indonesia. This research is a normative legal research. Data collected from books, journals, relevant laws and regulations. The results show that the government should either revise the current tax law and legal design that are obvious out-of-dated and dysfunctional or follow developed countries to have law specifically designed for taxing esports industry and e-economy.

Keywords

esports; live game streamer; platform; tax base

Full Text:

PDF

References

Book

Ali, Achmad, Menguak Teori Hukum (Legal Theory) dan Teori Peradilan (Judicialprudence) Termasuk Interpretasi Undang-Undang (Legisprudence) (Revealing Legal Theory and Judicial Theory, including Interpretation of Law), Jakarta: Kencana, (2017)

Deng, J., Cuardrado, F., Tyson, G., & Uhlig, S., Behind the Game: Exploring the Twitch Streaming Platform, 2015 International Workshop on Network and Systems Support for Games (NetGames), (2015)

King, D. L., & Delfabbro, P.H., Introdcution to Gaming and IGD, Internet Gaming Disorder, (2019)

M. Farouq, Hukum Pajak di Indonesia, Suatu Pengantar Ilmu Hukum Terapan di Bidang Perpajakan (Tax Law in Indonesia, An Introduction to Applied Legal Studies in the Field of Taxation), Jakarta: Prenada Media Group, (2018)

Zucman, G., The Hidden Wealth of Nations: The Scourge of Tax Havens, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, (2015)

Journal

Alstadseaster, A., Johannesen, N., & Zucman, G., Who Own the Wealth in Tax Havens? Macro Evidence and Implications for Global Inequality, Journal of Public Economics, 89-100, 90 (2018)

Bambang Satriya, Membangun Negara Hukum di Era Pemerintahan Presiden Joko Widodo (Building the State of Law in the Era of President Joko Widodo), Jurnal Panorama Hukum, Volume 1, No. 2, 43-54, 45 (2016)

Budi Rachman, Junita, et al, Esport Sebagai Sumber Soft Power Indonesia: Sosialisasi Kepada Anak Muda (Esports as a Source of Indonesian Soft Power: Socialization to Young People), CARADDE: Jurnal Pengabdian Kepada Masyarakat, Volume 3, Number 1, 43-52, 44 (2020)

Coskun Karadng, Neslihan, Internet Ortaminda Verilen Reklam Hizmetlernin Vergilendirilmesi (Taxation of Advertising Services Via the Internet), MAKALELER, Number 236, 74-89, 74 (2019)

Dian Lesari, Ainul, et. Al, Analisis Pelaksanaan Pengawasan Pengenaan Pajak Penghasilan Atas Penghasilan Youtubers Pada Direktorat Jendral Pajak Tahun 2018 (Analysis of the Implementation of the Supervision of Income Tax Imposition on Youtubers Income at the 2018 Directorate General of Tax), Jurnal Reformasi Administrasi, Volume 6, No. 2, 144-162, 145 (2019)

Faúndez-Ugalde, A., Mellado-Silva, R., & Aldunate-Lizana, E., Use of artificial intelligence by tax administrations: An analysis regarding taxpayers’ rights in Latin American countries. Computer Law & Security Review, 1-14, 1 (2020)

Gandolfi, E., To Watch or to Play, It Is in the Game: The Game Culture on Twitch.tv Among Performers, Play and Audiences, Journal of Gaming & Virtual Worlds, Volume 8, Number 1, 61-82, 64 (2016)

Imron Rizki A., Self Aseesment Sistem Sebagai Dasar Pemungutan Pajak di Indonesia (Self-Assessment as a Basis for Tax Collection in Indonesia), Kendari: Jurnal Al-‘Adl, Volume 11, Issue 2, 81-88, 84-85 (2018)

Kurniawan, Faidillah, E-sport dalam Fenomena Olahraga Kekinian (E-sports in the Current Sports Phenomenon), JORPRES (Jurnal Olahraga Prestasi), 15 (2), 61-66, 64 (2019)

Luban, D., Justice and Law, International Encyclopedia of the Social & Behavioral Sciences, 932-936, 932 (2015)

Nuramalia Hasanah, Susi Indriani, Efektifitas Pelaksanaan Self-Assessment System dan Modernisasi Administrasi Pajak Terhadap Kualitas Pelayanan Pajak (Studi Kasus Pada KPP Kebon Jeruk 1) (Effectiveness of Self-Assessment system Implementation and Modernization of Tax Administration on Tax Service Quality (Case Study on Kebun Jeruk 1), Semarang: Jurnal Ilmiah Wahana Akutansi, Volume 8, No. 1, 17-53, 17-18 (2013)

Van Dijck, J., Governing Digital Societies: Private Platforms, Public Values, Computer Law & Security Review, 36, 1-4, 1 (2019)

Vikansari, Ni Putu Suci, Prasa, I Wayan, Pengawasan Pengenaan Pajak Penghasilan Terhadap YouTubers Sebagai Pelaku Influencer di Platform Media Sosial YouTube (Supervision of Income Tax Imposition of YouTubers as Influencer on the Youtube Social Media Platform), Kertha Negara: Journal Ilmu HukumI, Volume 7, No. 2, 1-15, 13 (2019)

Wijaya Suparna, et. Al, Analisa Upaya Peningkatan Penerimaan Perpajakan Dari Penggalian Potensi Pajak Atas Penghasilan YouTuber (Analysis of Tax Revenue Improvement Efforts Potential Exploration Taxes on YouTuber’s Income), Journal Manajemen Keuangan Publik, Volume 1., No. 2, 125-130, 128 (2017)

Zhao, Q., Chen, C.-D., Chen, H.-W., & Wang, J.-L., Determinants of Live Streamers’ Continuance Broadcasting Intention on Twitch: A Self-Determination Theory Perspective, Telematics and Informatics, 406-420, 406. (2018)

Zhou, J., Zhou, J., Ding, Y., & Wang, H., The Magic of Danmaku: A Sosial Interaction Perspective of Gift Sending on Live Streaming Platforms, Electronic Commerce Research and Applications, 1-9, 1 (2019)

Legislation

Constitution of Republic of Indonesia

Law No. 36 of 2008 on Income Tax

Law No. 6 of 1983 jo Law No. 16 of 2000 on General Provision and Tax Procedures

Directorate General Tax Regulation No.PER-17/JP/2015 on the norm of Net Income Calculation

Website

Aditya, David, Dapat Gaji dari Facebook Lewat Live Streaming Game Favoritmu (Get Salaries from Facebook through Live Streaming of Your Favorite Games), available at http://www.purwakartapost.co.id/16/07/2019/hiburan/dapat-gaji-dari-facebook-lewat-live-streaming-game-favoritmu/19333/ (last visited June 7, 2020)

Anggraeni, Lufthi, IESPL: Indonesia Peringkat 12 Pasar Gaming Dunia (IESPL: Indonesia Ranked 12th in the World Gaming Market), available at https://www.medcom.id/teknologi/game/ybDl83Pb-iespl-indonesia-peringkat-12-pasar-gaming-dunia (last visited August 14, 2020)

Anonymous, Sejarah Perkembangan IeSPA (History of IeSPA), available at http://www.iespa.or.id/sejarah-perkembangan/ (last visited May 19, 2020)

Alexy Robert, Gustav Radbruch’s Concept of Law, available at https://www.upjs.sk/public/media/16913/Gustav%20Radbruch%27s%20Concept%20of%20Law.pdf (last visited July 12, 2020

Arif Budiansyah, Ini Penghasilan 13 YouTuber Gaming Indonesia, Ratusan Juta Coy! (This is the income of 13th YouuTuber Gaming Indonesia, Hundreds Millions Coy!), available at https://nextren.grid.id/read/011800565/ini-penghasilan-13-youtuber-gaming-indonesia-ratusan-juta-coy (last visited June 5, 2020)

Ayudiana, Shofi, Peraturan Mentri Soal Esport Rampung Sebelum SEA Games 2019 (Ministerial Regulation Concerning Esports Completed Before the 2019 SEA Games), available at https://www.antaranews.com/berita/1091884/peraturan-menteri-soal-esport-rampung-sebelum-sea-games-2019 (last visited August 20, 2020)

Bountie Gaming, There’s A Huge Untapped Market For The Esports Industry In Asia & You’ll Lose Out If You Ignore It, available at https://medium.com/swlh/theres-a-huge-untapped-market-for-the-esports-industry-in-asia-you-ll-lose-out-if-you-ignore-it-cb261cc8cea (last visited May 19, 2020)

BPPM Mahkamah, Endorsers: Wajib pajak atau sekedar Subjek Pajak? (Endorsers: Taxpayers or jus Tax Subjects?), available at https://mahkamahnews.org/2019/09/03/endorsers-wajib-pajak-atau-sekadar-subjek-pajak/ (last visited August 5, 2020)

Celebrity Net Worth, how much is Tyler “Ninja” Blevins Net Worth? available at https://www.celebritynetworth.com/richest-celebrities/rock-stars/tyler-ninja-blevins-net-worth/ (last visited May 9, 2020)

Clinten, Bill, Begini Cara Gamer Dapat Uang dari Facebook Gaming (Here’s How Gamers Can Earn Money form Facebook Gaming), available at https://tekno.kompas.com/read/2020/05/08/19150007/begini-cara-gamer-dapat-uang-dari-facebook-gaming?page=all (last visited June 28, 2020)

CNBC Indonesia, Halo Gamers, Ini Cara Dapat Uang dari Facebook Gaming! (Hallo Gamers, Here’s How to Make Money from Facebook Gaming!), available at https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/tech/20200511170036-37-157674/halo-gamers-ini-cara-dapat-uang-dari-facebook-gaming (last visited July 8, 2020)

CNBC, Here’s why esports can become a billion-dollar industry in 2019, available at https://www.cnbc.com/2019/01/20/heres-why-esports-can-become-a-billion-dollar-industry-in-2019.html (last visited February 2, 2020)

Ellavie Ichlasa A., Populer Secara Global, Twitch Tak Berkutik di Indonesia (Globally Famous, Twitch Does Not Do Anything in Indonesia), available at https://hybrid.co.id/post/populer-secara-global-twitch-tak-berkutik-di-indonesia (last visited June 4, 2020)

Fachri, Ananda, Seberapa Besar Potensi E-Sports di Indonesia (How Big is the Potential of E-Sports in Indonesia), available at https://www.kompasiana.com/anandafachri/5e676f0e097f362c062a2f34/seberapa-besar-potensi-e-sport-di-indonesia (last visited August 18, 2020)

Ichlasa Amalia, Ellavie, Daftar Turnamen Esports Berhadia Terbesar di Indonesia 2019 (List of the Biggest Prize eSports Tournaments in Indonesia), available at https://hybrid.co.id/post/daftar-turnamen-esports-berhadiah-terbesar-di-indonesia-2019 (last visited August 18, 2020)

Ichlasa Amalia, Ellavie, Kenapa Investor Percaya Esports Bakal Jadi Industri Bernilai US$1 Milliar? (Why do Investors believe that esports will be a US$1 Billion Industry?), available at https://hybrid.co.id/post/nilai-industri-esports (last visited August 18, 2020)

Ichlasa Amalia, Ellavie, IDC:Viewership Turnamen Esports Naik 2 Kali Lipat Selama Pandami Corona (IDC: Viewership of Esports Tournaments Doubled During the Corona Pandemic), available at https://hybrid.co.id/post/idc-viewership-turnamen-esports-naik-2-kali-lipat-selama-pandemi-corona (last visited August 20, 2020)

Ichlasa Amalia, Ellavie, Bagaimana Pengaruh Corona Pada Audiens Esports? (How Does Corona Affect the Esports Audience?), available at https://hybrid.co.id/post/bagaimana-pengaruh-corona-pada-audiens-esports (last visited August 20, 2020)

Indopajak.id, SONETA si Pemantau Pajak (SONETA the Tax Monitor), available at https://indopajak.id/pemantau-pajak-selebgram-dan-youtubers/ (last visited June 7, 2020)

Iqbal, Mansoor, Twitch Revenue and Usage Statistics (2020), available at https://www.businessofapps.com/data/twitch-statistics/ (last visited July 17, 2020)

Iskandar, Merdi, Pemerintah Indonesia Dorong Pengembangan eSports Nasional (Indonesian Government Encourages the Development of National eSports), available https://wartakota.tribunnews.com/2020/07/01/pemerintah-indonesia-dorong-pengembangan-esports-nasional (last visited July 17, 2020)

Julita S., Lidya, Saat Dirjen Kemenkeu Cerita Kenapa Susah Memajaki Google Cs (When Director General of Ministry of Finance Tells Why It’s Difficult to Tax Google Cs), available at https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/tech/20190717154401-37-85636/saat-dirjen-kemenkeu-cerita-kenapa-susah-memajaki-google-cs (last visited August 5, 2020)

Kusuma Aji, 4 Nama Besar Platform Streaming Terkait Video Games Beserta Pros Dan Cons (4 Name of the Platform Related Streaming Video Games And Its Pros And Cons), available at https://gamebrott.com/4-nama-besar-platform-streaming-terkait-video-games-beserta-pros-dan-cons (last visited June 4, 2020)

Liana B. Baker, Rory Carroll, Esports get a cool reception at Winter Games, available at https://www.reuters.com/article/us-olympics-2018-esports-idUSKBN1FR13Y (last visited May 16, 2020)

Newzoo, The Global Esports Audience Will Be just Shy of 500 Million This Year, available at https://newzoo.com/insights/articles/newzoo-esports-sponsorship-alone-will-generate-revenues-of-more-than-600-million-this-year/ (last visited February 4, 2020)

Nurhayat, Wiji, Ekonomi Digital Jadi Tantangan Terberat Dirjen Pajak (Digital Economy Becomes the Most Challenging Director General of Taxes), available at https://kumparan.com/kumparanbisnis/ekonomi-digital-jadi-tantangan-terberat-ditjen-pajak-27431110790545513/full (last visited August 5, 2020)

Malena, Industri Gaming Tumbuh 20 Persen, Ini 3 Alasan eSports Kian Populer (Gaming Industry Grows 20 Percent, These are 3 Reason eSports is Gaining More Popular), available at http://www.kalderanews.com/2020/07/industri-gaming-tumbuh-20-persen-ini-3-alasan-esports-kian-populer/ (last visited August 18, 2020)

Muhammad, Fikiri, Bagaimana Cara Agar Youtuber Indonesia Mau Bayar Pajak? (How do you get Indonesian YouTubers to Pay Taxes?), available at https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/news/20190113154724-4-50418/bagaimana-cara-agar-youtuber-indonesia-mau-bayar-pajak (last visited August 5, 2020)

P., Situmorang, Anggun, Ini Alasan YouTuber dan Selebgram Mangkir Bayar Pajak (This is the Reason Why YouTuber and Celebirty are Absent from Paying Taxes), available at https://www.merdeka.com/uang/ini-alasan-youtuber-dan-selebgram-mangkir-bayar-pajak.html (last visited August 5, 2020)

Rintang Azhar, eSports are at the Brink of Recoqnition as Athletes and Olympians, available at https://nowjakarta.co.id/life/techno/esports-are-at-the-brink-of-recognition-as-athletes-and-olympians (last visited May 19, 2020)

Rifki, Billy, Kemenpora “Godok” Undang-Undang Esports, Manfaatnya apa? (The Minister of Youth and Sports “Push” the Esports Law, What are the benefits?), available at https://esports.id/other/news/2020/02/0de5d1a081a3095d62b416e44e055e7a/kemenpora-godok-undang-undang-esports-manfaatnya-apa (last visited August 20, 2020)

Rifka Sri Rahayu, Isna, Sri Mulyani Beberkan Tantangan Dirjen Pajak di Era Digital (Sri Mulyani Outlines the Challenges of the Director General of Taxes in the Digital Era), available at https://www.inews.id/finance/makro/sri-mulyani-beberkan-tantangan-ditjen-pajak-di-era-digital (last visited August 5, 2020)

Rizkia, Choiru, Bisakah Skema Pungut Pajak Netfilx Mencontek Singapura? (Can Indonesia Imitate Singapore on the Netflix Tax Collection Scheme?), available at https://technologue.id/bisakah-skema-pungut-pajak-netflix-mencontek-singapura/amp/ (last visited August 25, 2020)

Rizkia, Choiru, Tiga Cara Gamer Menghasilkan Uang Dari Faceboook Gaming (Three Ways Gamers Make Money from Facebook Gaming), available at https://technologue.id/tiga-cara-menghasilkan-uang-dari-facebook-gaming/amp/ (last visited July 8, 2020)

Rizki Nugraha, Aditia, Sejarah eSports Indonesia: Dari Warnet Menuju Panggung Dunia (History of Indonesian eSports: From Internet Cafes to the World Stage), available at https://kumparan.com/kumparansport/sejarah-esports-indonesia-dari-warnet-menuju-panggung-dunia-1533295225512257378/full (last visited August 18, 2020)

Sam Nordmark and Jerome Heath, The top 10 highest prize pools in eSports, available at https://dotesports.com/general/news/biggest-prize-pools-esports-14605 (last visited May 16, 2020)

Setyo Wardani, Agustin, Menakar Format Turnamen Esports di Masa Pandemi (Measuring the Format of Esports Tournaments during the Pandemic), available at https://www.liputan6.com/tekno/read/4311170/menakar-format-turnamen-esports-di-masa-pandemi (last visited August 20, 2020)

Social Blade, Jess No Limit’s YouTube Stats Summary, available at https://socialblade.com/youtube/channel/UCvh1at6xpV1ytYOAzxmqUsA (last visited May 9, 2020)

Triyadi, Bogi, Kemenpora dan IESPL Gelar Piala Menpora Esports 2020 (Kemenpora and IESPL Hold Menpora Esports Cup 2020), available at https://www.liputan6.com/bola/read/4322609/kemenpora-dan-iespl-gelar-piala-menpora-esports-2020 (last visited August 20, 2020)

World Economic Forum, The explosive growth of eSports, available at https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2018/07/the-explosive-growth-of-esports/ (last visited February 6, 2020)

Yadika, Bawono, Facebook, YouTube dan Twitter Diminta Tiru Google soal Bayar Pajak (Facebook, YouTube and Twitter asked to imitate Google about Paying Taxes), available at https://www.liputan6.com/bisnis/read/4052109/facebook-youtube-dan-twitter-diminta-tiru-google-soal-bayar-pajak (last visited August 25, 2020)

Zainal Arifin, Nanang, BEPS Dalam Kerangka Kerja Sama G20 dan Implementasinya Kepad Indonesia (BEPS In the Framework of G20 Cooperation and Its Implementation to Indonesia), available at https://www.kemenkeu.go.id/sites/default/files/beps%20dalam%20kerangka%20kerja%20sama%20g20%20dan%20implementasinya%20kepada%20indonesia.pdf (last visited August 5, 2020)

DOI: https://doi.org/10.18196/jmh.20200148