A Libertarian Legitimacy for Mandatory Covid-19 Vaccination

Yudi Setiawan; Zaid Zaid; Nanik Prasetyoningsih; Mahbub Pasca Al Bahy

doi:10.18196/jmh.v29i2.14313

A Libertarian Legitimacy for Mandatory Covid-19 Vaccination

Yudi Setiawan, Zaid Zaid, Nanik Prasetyoningsih, Mahbub Pasca Al Bahy

Abstract

Since its inception, the 2019 coronavirus disease (Covid-19) outbreak has become a major health problem. At the same time, countries worldwide have been waiting for a Covid-19 vaccine to be sufficiently available. When the Covid-19 vaccine became available, several countries began to adopt mandatory Covid-19 vaccination policies. However, mandatory Covid-19 vaccination has received strong opposition from the start. Rejections have emerged from various parties, including from libertarians. The researcher observes that the current research attempting to analyze the mandatory Covid-19 vaccination still revolves around the perspective of human rights and utilitarianism. Then, this study aims to explore and find out how the libertarian perspective toward mandatory vaccination. Normative research methods with conceptual and comparative approaches were used in this study. After analyzing secondary data sources with prescriptive analysis methods, this study finally succeeded in finding that mandatory Covid-19 vaccination has its place, legitimacy, and justification on the ideological side of libertarianism. It is because libertarians accept that the government may require a mandatory vaccination program against Covid-19. In addition, due to the libertarian framework, the government is still justified in enforcing coercive policies that violate the rights of certain individuals if the policy is necessary to avoid greater harm to others.

Keywords

covid-19; libertarianism; mandatory vaccination

Full Text:

PDF

References

Achat, H. M., Stubbs, J. M., & Mittal, R. (2021). Australian Healthcare Workers and COVID-19 Vaccination: Is Mandating Now or For Future Variants Necessary? Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health, 46(1), 95-96. https://doi.org/10.1111/1753-6405.13191

Adamy, A., & Rani, H. A. (2022). An evaluation of community satisfaction with the government’s COVID-19 pandemic response in Aceh, Indonesia. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 69, 102723. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.IJDRR.2021.102723

Ahmed, A., Aqeel, M., & Aslam, N. (2020). COVID-19 health crisis and prevalence of anxiety among individuals of various age groups: a qualitative study. Journal of Mental Health Training, Education and Practice, 16(1), 58–66. https://doi.org/10.1108/JMHTEP-07-2020-0046

Ashwell, D., Cullinane, J., & Croucher, S. M. (2021). Vaccine Hesitancy and Support for Employer Vaccine Mandates. Frontiers in Communication, 6, 250–259. https://doi.org/10.3389/FCOMM.2021.780415/BIBTEX

Attwell, K., Rizzi, M., McKenzie, L., Carlson, S. J., Roberts, L., Tomkinson, S., & Blyth, C. C. (2021). COVID-19 vaccine Mandates: An Australian attitudinal study. Vaccine. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.VACCINE.2021.11.056

Bauer, A., Tiefengraber, D., & Wiedermann, U. (2021). Towards understanding vaccine hesitancy and vaccination refusal in Austria. Wiener Klinische Wochenschrift, 133(13–14), 703–713. https://doi.org/10.1007/S00508-020-01777-9/FIGURES/7

Bernstein, J. (2017). The case against libertarian arguments for compulsory vaccination. Journal of Medical Ethics, 43(11), 792–796. https://doi.org/10.1136/medethics-2016-103857

Block, W. E. (2020). A Libertarian Analysis of the COVID-19 Pandemic. Journal of Libertarian Studies, 24, 206–237.

Boniolo, G. (2016). Public Obligation and Individual Freedom: How to Fill the Gap? The Case of Vaccinations. Journal of Public Health Research, 5(2), 58–59. https://doi.org/10.4081/JPHR.2016.732

Bradfield, O. M., & Giubilini, A. (2021). Spoonful of honey or a gallon of vinegar? A conditional COVID-19 vaccination policy for front-line healthcare workers. Journal of Medical Ethics, 47(7), 467–472. https://doi.org/10.1136/MEDETHICS-2020-107175

Brennan, J. (2018). A libertarian case for mandatory vaccination. Journal of Medical Ethics, 44(1), 37–43. https://doi.org/10.1136/MEDETHICS-2016-103486

Butler, J., & Sorell, T. (2022). Does Libertarianism Provide a Justification for Vaccine Hesitancy? The Political Quarterly, 93(2), 342–346. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-923X.13136

Camilleri, F. (2019). Compulsory vaccinations for children: Balancing the competing human rights at stake. Netherlands Quarterly of Human Rights, 37(3), 245–267. https://doi.org/10.1177/0924051919861797

Chirumbolo, S. (2021). Vaccination hesitancy and the “myth” on mRNA-based vaccines in Italy in the COVID-19 era: Does urgency meet major safety criteria? Journal of Medical Virology, 93(7), 4049–4053. https://doi.org/10.1002/JMV.26922

Davidson, M. D. (2021). How Fairness Principles in the Climate Debate Relate to Theories of Distributive Justice. Sustainability, 13(13), 7302. https://doi.org/10.3390/SU13137302

De Panfilis, L., Peruselli, C., Artioli, G., Perin, M., Bruera, E., Brazil, K., & Tanzi, S. (2021). A Qualitative Study on Nudging and Palliative Care: “An Attractive but Misleading Concept.” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2021, Vol. 18, Page 9575, 18(18), 9575–9582. https://doi.org/10.3390/IJERPH18189575

Debus, M., & Tosun, J. (2021). Political ideology and vaccination willingness: implications for policy design. Policy Sciences, 54(3), 477–491. https://doi.org/10.1007/S11077-021-09428-0/TABLES/1

Delanty, G. (2020). Six political philosophies in search of a virus: Critical perspectives on the coronavirus pandemic. LSE ‘Europe in Question’ Discussion Paper Series, (156), 1–17. Retrieved from https://www.lse.ac.uk/european-institute/Assets/Documents/LEQS-Discussion-Papers/LEQSPaper156.pdf

Fauziah, M. (2022). Urgency of Indonesia to Establish a Comprehensive COVID-19 Pandemic Law: Lesson Learned from Singapore. Indonesian Comparative Law Review, 4(1), 1-16. https://doi.org/10.18196/iclr.v4i1.12999

Flanigan, J. (2013). A Defense of Compulsory Vaccination. HEC Forum, 26(1), 5–25. https://doi.org/10.1007/S10730-013-9221-5

García-Toledano, E., López-Parra, E., Cebrián-Martínez, A., & Palomares-Ruiz, A. (2022). Inclusive Education for Health: Analysis of the Mandatory Nature of Vaccination and Its Regulation by Administrations, and Implications and Considerations for Vaccination against COVID. Vaccines, 10(1), 73–90. https://doi.org/10.3390/VACCINES10010073

Giannouchos, T. V., Steletou, E., Saridi, M., & Souliotis, K. (2021a). Mandatory vaccination support and intentions to get vaccinated for COVID-19: Results from a nationally representative general population survey in October 2020 in Greece. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 27(4), 996–1003. https://doi.org/10.1111/JEP.13588

Giannouchos, T. V., Steletou, E., Saridi, M., & Souliotis, K. (2021b). Should vaccination be mandated? Individuals’ perceptions on mandatory vaccination in Greece. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 27(5), 1104–1111. https://doi.org/10.1111/JEP.13568

Giubilini, A. (2019). Vaccination Policies and the Principle of Least Restrictive Alternative: An Intervention Ladder. The Ethics of Vaccination, 59–93. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-02068-2_3

Giubilini, A. (2020). An Argument for Compulsory Vaccination: The Taxation Analogy. Journal of Applied Philosophy, 37(3), 446–466. https://doi.org/10.1111/JAPP.12400

Giubilini, A., & Savulescu, J. (2019). Vaccination, Risks, and Freedom: The Seat Belt Analogy. Public Health Ethics, 12(3), 237–249. https://doi.org/10.1093/PHE/PHZ014

Giubilini, A., Douglas, T., & Savulescu, J. (2018). The moral obligation to be vaccinated: utilitarianism, contractualism, and collective easy rescue. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy, 21(4), 547–560. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-018-9829-y

Graeber, D., Schmidt-Petri, C., & Schröder, C. (2021). Attitudes on voluntary and mandatory vaccination against COVID-19: Evidence from Germany. PLOS ONE, 16(5), e0248372. https://doi.org/10.1371/JOURNAL.PONE.0248372

Gravagna, K., Becker, A., Valeris-Chacin, R., Mohammed, I., Tambe, S., Awan, F. A., Toomey, T. L., & Basta, N. E. (2020). Global assessment of national mandatory vaccination policies and consequences of non-compliance. Vaccine, 38(49), 7865–7873. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.VACCINE.2020.09.063

Gunawan, Y., & Irrynta, D. (2022). International Human Rights Protection: The Impact of COVID-19 Pandemic on Domestic Violence. Yustisia Jurnal Hukum, 11(1), 16-28. https://dx.doi.org/10.20961/yustisia.v11i1.58872

Haberer, J. E., van der Straten, A., Safren, S. A., Johnson, M. O., Amico, K. R., del Rio, C., Andrasik, M., Wilson, I. B & Simoni, J. M. (2021). Individual health behaviours to combat the COVID-19 pandemic: lessons from HIV socio-behavioural science. Journal of the International AIDS Society, 24(8), e25771. https://doi.org/10.1002/JIA2.25771

Iyer, R., Koleva, S., Graham, J., Ditto, P., & Haidt, J. (2012). Understanding Libertarian Morality: The Psychological Dispositions of Self-Identified Libertarians. PLOS ONE, 7(8), e42366. https://doi.org/10.1371/JOURNAL.PONE.0042366

Jacobson, R. M., Agunwamba, A. A., St. Sauver, J. L., & Rutten, L. J. F. (2015). The most effective and promising population health strategies to advance human papillomavirus vaccination. Expert Review of Vaccines, 15(2), 257–269. https://doi.org/10.1586/14760584.2016.1116947

Kates, O. S., Stock, P. G., Ison, M. G., Allen, R. D. M., Burra, P., Jeong, J. C., Kute, V., Muller, E., Nino-Murcia, A., Wang, H., & Wall, A. (2021). Ethical review of COVID-19 vaccination requirements for transplant center staff and patients. American Journal of Transplantation, 00, 1–10. https://doi.org/10.1111/AJT.16878

Khunti, K., Kamal, A., Pareek, M., & Griffiths, A. (2021). Should vaccination for healthcare workers be mandatory? Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 114(5), 235–236. https://doi.org/10.1177/01410768211013525

Koyama, M. (2021). Epidemic disease and the state: Is there a tradeoff between public health and liberty? Public Choice 2021, 1–23. https://doi.org/10.1007/S11127-021-00944-4

Lantos, J. D., & Jackson, M. A. (2013). Vaccine Mandates Are Justifiable Because We Are All in This Together. The American Journal of Bioethics, 13(9), 1–2. https://doi.org/10.1080/15265161.2013.815021

Leask, J., Seale, H., Williams, J. H., Kaufman, J., Wiley, K., Mahimbo, A., Clark, K. K., Danchin, M. H., & Attwell, K. (2021). Policy considerations for mandatory COVID-19 vaccination from the Collaboration on Social Science and Immunisation. Medical Journal of Australia, 215(11), 499–503. https://doi.org/10.5694/MJA2.51269

Millar, M. R., Gourtsoyannis, Y., & Jayakumar, A. (2021). Ethics of vaccination: Should capability measures be used to inform SARS-CoV-2 vaccination strategies? British Journal of Clinical Pharmacology, 88(1), 47–55. https://doi.org/10.1111/BCP.14875

Moller, D. (2019). Governing least: a New England libertarianism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Navin, M. C. (2015). Values and Vaccine Refusal: Hard Questions in Ethics, Epistemology, and Health Care. New York: Routledge.

Odone, A., Dallagiacoma, G., Frascella, B., Signorelli, C., & Leask, J. (2021). Current understandings of the impact of mandatory vaccination laws in Europe. Expert Review of Vaccines, 20(5), 559–575. https://doi.org/10.1080/14760584.2021.1912603

Panagopoulou, F. (2021). Mandatory Vaccination during the Period of a Pandemic: Legal and Ethical Considerations in Europe. BioTech, 10(4), 29–42. https://doi.org/10.3390/BIOTECH10040029

Paterlini, M. (2021). Covid-19: Italy makes vaccination mandatory for healthcare workers. BMJ, 373, n905. https://doi.org/10.1136/BMJ.N905

Paul, K. T., & Loer, K. (2019). Contemporary vaccination policy in the European Union: tensions and dilemmas. Journal of Public Health Policy, 40(2), 166–179. https://doi.org/10.1057/S41271-019-00163-8/FIGURES/1

Piccirilli, G., Lazzarotto, T., Chiereghin, A., Serra, L., Gabrielli, L., & Lanari, M. (2015). Spotlight on measles in Italy: why outbreaks of a vaccine-preventable infection continue in the 21st century. Expert Review of Anti-Infective Therapy, 13(3), 355–362. https://doi.org/10.1586/14787210.2015.1003808

Pierik, R. (2017). On religious and secular exemptions: A case study of childhood vaccination waivers. Ethnicities, 17(2), 220–241. https://doi.org/10.1177/1468796817692629

Pierik, R. (2018). Mandatory Vaccination: An Unqualified Defence. Journal of Applied Philosophy, 35(2), 381–398. https://doi.org/10.1111/JAPP.12215

Presidential Regulation of the Republic of Indonesia Number 14 of 2021 concerning Amendments to Presidential Regulation Number 99 of 2020 concerning Vaccine Procurement and Vaccination Implementation in the Context of Combating the 2019 Corona Virus Disease Pandemic (Covid-19).

Prieto Curiel, R., & González Ramírez, H. (2021). Vaccination strategies against COVID-19 and the diffusion of anti-vaccination views. Scientific Reports 2021 11:1, 11(1), 1–13. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-85555-1

Refisyanti, S. (2022). Constitutional Obligations of Indonesian Government During Covid-19 Pandemic: A Critical Appraisal. Indonesian Comparative Law Review, 3(2), 135-151. https://doi.org/10.18196/iclr.v3i2.11768

Regulation of the Minister of Health of the Republic of Indonesia Number 10 of 2021 concerning the Implementation of Vaccination in the Context of Combating the Corona Virus Disease 2019 (Covid-19) Pandemic.

Rezza, G. (2019). Mandatory vaccination for infants and children: the Italian experience. Pathogens and Global Health, 113(7), 291–296. https://doi.org/10.1080/20477724.2019.1705021

Rogers, K. A. (2015). Freedom and Self-Creation Anselmian Libertarianism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Saied, S. M., Saied, E. M., Kabbash, I. A., & Abdo, S. A. E. F. (2021). Vaccine hesitancy: Beliefs and barriers associated with COVID-19 vaccination among Egyptian medical students. Journal of Medical Virology, 93(7), 4280–4291. https://doi.org/10.1002/JMV.26910

Savulescu, J., Persson, I., & Wilkinson, D. (2020). Utilitarianism and the pandemic. Bioethics, 34(6), 620–632. https://doi.org/10.1111/bioe.12771

Savulescu, J., Pugh, J., & Wilkinson, D. (2021). Balancing incentives and disincentives for vaccination in a pandemic. Nature Medicine, 27(9), 1500–1503. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41591-021-01466-8

Schmelz, K. (2020). Enforcement may crowd out voluntary support for COVID-19 policies, especially where trust in government is weak and in a liberal society. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 118(1), 1–8. https://doi.org/10.1073/PNAS.2016385118/-/DCSUPPLEMENTAL

Schwartz, J. L. (2013). Evidence and Ethics in Mandatory Vaccination Policies. American Journal of Bioethics, 13(9), 46–48. https://doi.org/10.1080/15265161.2013.815023

Silverman, R. D., & Wiley, L. F. (2018). Shaming Vaccine Refusal. The Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics, 45(4), 569–581. https://doi.org/10.1177/1073110517750597

Silverstein, A. (2021). Vaccine mandates: A transplant recipient’s perspective. American Journal of Transplantation, 22(2), 35-336. https://doi.org/10.1111/AJT.16908

Sprengholz, P., Betsch, C., & Böhm, R. (2021). Reactance revisited: Consequences of mandatory and scarce vaccination in the case of COVID-19. Applied Psychology: Health and Well-Being, 13(4), 986–995. https://doi.org/10.1111/APHW.12285

Steiner, H. (2019). Asymmetric information, libertarianism, and fraud. Review of Social Economy, 77(2), 94–107. https://doi.org/10.1080/00346764.2019.1602280

Tomljenovic, H., Bubic, A., & Hren, D. (2020). Decision making processes underlying avoidance of mandatory child vaccination in Croatia – a qualitative study. Current Psychology, 1–15. https://doi.org/10.1007/S12144-020-01110-7/TABLES/2

Velan, B. (2011). Acceptance on the move: Public reaction to shifting vaccination realities. Human Vaccines, 7(12), 1261–1270. https://doi.org/10.4161/HV.7.12.17980

Velan, B., Boyko, V., Lerner-Geva, L., Ziv, A., Yagar, Y., & Kaplan, G. (2012). Individualism, acceptance and differentiation as attitude traits in the public’s response to vaccination. Human Vaccines & Immunotherapeutics, 8(9), 1272–1282. https://doi.org/10.4161/HV.21183

Zaid, Z., Hernowo, Wempy S., & Prasetyoningsih, N. (2022). Mandatory COVID-19 vaccination in human rights and utilitarianism perspectives, International Journal of Public Health Science, 11(3), 967-974. http://doi.org/10.11591/ijphs.v11i3.21412

Zaid. (2021). La Escuela De Salamanca: Pengantar Sejarah dan Konsep Pemikiran Mazhab Salamanca. Lamongan: Academia Publication.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.18196/jmh.v29i2.14313